Poppy O'Hair tries to decide whether she's a Royal or Rebel—or a little of both.
A carriage drops off a girl, who the female narrator announces to be Poppy O'Hair. Her twin sister, Holly, greets Poppy with gusto. It's Poppy's first day at Ever After High, and that she does not have a legacy because Holly was born first.
Baba Yaga asks Poppy if she has picked her classes yet. Poppy is unable to choose because most of them sound enjoyable. As classes start the next day, Yaga urges her to choose. Holly asks how her choosing her schedule went, and Poppy tells her that she must choose a destiny by tomorrow. Holly advises her sister that she should ask other students what they think about destiny.
First on is Apple White, who utters it's not easy being a Royal, but it is worth it to be with princes and live in castles. Next is Tiny, who states that if a Rebel, the villain role is optional. Briar Beauty voices that being a Royal is living every day to the fullest. Cerise comes along, telling Poppy that just being herself is most important. Poppy agrees, and asks about Cerise's highlights, getting close to taking off her hood. Cerise quickly claims that her mother does them and runs off.
At the end of the day, the O'Hair twins meet in the common room. Holly asks Poppy what side she's picked, and Poppy declares she's not going to take a side. Instead she has been inspired to take on both values and be a Roybel.
- Holly O'Hair makes her cartoon debut.
- Holly's legs switch around when she hugs Poppy.