Maddie helps a new friend from feeling like a fish out of water after the mysterious fairytale arrives on the same day as the Ever After High talent show!
Madeline, Briar, and Ashlynn are in the Castleteria, with Madeline showing her trick for the talent show next "Chapterday" (Saturday), when Briar spots the new girl, Meeshell. Ashlynn, Briar, and Maddie invite her over, but Madeline accidentally spills some tea onto the floor and on Meeshell's feet. Meeshell gets shy and runs off. Maddie, Briar and Ashlynn bring a snap-dragon flower to Meeshell's dorm, but she still acts very shy. Later on, Ashlynn, Madeline and Briar go off talking about Meeshell's shyness in the hallway, but when they hear singing in the Grimmnastics swim class room, they go in. They discover that Meeshell is a mermaid and that she has an excellent singing voice. Meeshell apologizes to them for running away, and explains her lack of confidence when on land. They have Meeshell sing in the talent show, to which she does a really great job to. Madeline shows them the biggest cup of tea ever, to which takes a long time, so Meeshell does an encore.
- Meeshell makes her webisode introduction, but not webisode debut. Her webisode debut was in "Beanstalk Bravado".