WebisodesHolly welcomes her sister, Poppy, to Ever After High. Baba Yaga asks Poppy if she has picked her classes yet. Poppy is unable to choose most of them sound enjoyable. As classes start the next day, Yaga urges her to choose. Holly asks how her choosing her schedule went, and Poppy tells her that she must choose a destiny by tomorrow. Holly advises her sister that she should ask other students what they think about destiny. At the end of the day, the O'Hair twins meet in the common room. Holly asks Poppy what side she's picked, and Poppy declares she's not going to take a side. Instead she has been inspired to take on both values and be a Roybel. Holly is told by Poppy the truth that it's her not Holly who's the older twin, and thus is meant to be the next Rapunzel. Holly gets an idea: keep this discovery a secret, and keep the destinies they want. Poppy happily agrees.
Holly helps set up decorations for the dance. She dreamily watches as the bookball team plan for the big game. She visits Heritage Hall and she Poppy are given magic hairbrushes by their mother. Holly plays a game of cards with her friends. She prepares for the Thronecoming dance. She attends the Thronecoming dance.
She attends the class field trip to the Legacy Orchard. Duchess's challenge, and Holly states that she shouldn't be taken by fear. Poppy follows her advice. Holly watches Apple and Raven's croquet match. Holly watches the planting of the E-corn.Holly is part of cooking class. Along with her sister, she sits on the bench. Poppy is unsure if she should step up to
TV specialsKitty who is the causer of the Fairest Wheel fiasco. Holly is excited at the new appearance of the Wonderlandians. Holly enters the Chef Showdown and receives a good result from Jack Horner. At the end of the contest, she goes over to Raven's table and asks what's wrong. She and Raven ask Ashlynn for directions, but she isn't eager on helping. Holly and Raven find Apple in school and notice what's been happening with Apple. Holly is unsuccessful in unplugging the well, so she runs to Book End and pleads Apple to help, but she is consumed by the curse. Holly enjoys a day of happiness in the Spring Fairest with her friends and would fret on the missing Storybook another time. Holly has breakfast in the castleteria.
Ashlynn goes to Holly and Poppy's room to check if they and Farrah are ready to go at her boyfriend Hunter's party. Ashlynn notices they are too suited up for a woodland party and they answer Faybelle has invited them to her party, and if they don't show, she'll cast a spell on them. Ashlynn is disappointed that Faybelle's patry is on the same night, but then she gets an idea. At the Faybelle Formal, Faybelle is welcoming the guests. Ashlynn, Holly, Poppy and Farrah arrive, but leave shortly after, by making an excuse that they forgot to bring their cupcakes. They quickly rush to the bathroom, where Farrah transforms they're outfits and hair to look suitable for Hunter's party. When the girls get back to Faybelle's party, they soon realize they for got to change their causal outfits back into their formal gowns. Faybelle is insulted and accuses them of sneaking out to go to a different party, and prepares to put a curse on them. But then Ashlynn tells Faybelle that there's a carousel at the other party. Faybelle squeals with delight while she rides the carousel at Hunter's party. The parties have been combined and everyone is happy.