Duchess Swan believes she's destined to fail her Muse-ic Class project--until Humphrey Dumpty lends a hand.
Humphrey Dumpty has his eyes on a new omelette he's been planning to make. Unfortunately for him, however, he trips down the stairs, breaking his eggs. Apple is eager to lend a hand and summon workers to repair him—and his eggs. As well, Apple mentions to do good towards another person.
Following Apple's suggestion, Humphrey hears someone sobbing by the lake. An upset Duchess apprises Humphrey of her struggle with a Muse-ic project, considering the fact that she can't sing. Afraid of her grades lowering, it's Humphrey's chance to do a good deed for Duchess.
It's Muse-ic class and Duchess is picked by Professor Piper to exhibit her project in front of the class. Suspecting that she won't do a good job, Duchess surprises everyone with a negative response. Causing murmurs around the class, Humphrey butts in and manifests Duchess's dancing video as an act-out of her story. Professor Piper easily gives her an A plus. Thanking Humphrey, Duchess wonders how she'd compensate for such a great deed he's done. Humphrey tells her the same thing Apple told him: paying it forward.
- The webisode title is a play on the expression "best foot forward".